Skip to content

LETTER: Reader presents an alternative proposal to pumped storage

Clean Air Alliance chair proposes extending transmission lines to use water power from Quebec during Ontario's peak demand
writing AdobeStock_130194346
Stock image

This letter was submitted in response to a proposed hydroelectric pumped storage facility in Meaford on the military base lands. CollingwoodToday welcomes letters to the editor. They can be emailed to [email protected].

***********************

Dear Editor,

TC Energy is seeking a contract from the Government of Ontario to finance the construction of its proposed $3.3 billion Georgian Bay pumped storage project (“TC Energy claims pump project part of conservation solution” – October 27).

According to TC Energy, this project is the “most, proven economical” way to provide us with 1,000 megawatts of peak power to help phase-out Ontario’s gas-fired power plants. 

This is simply not true. We have much lower-cost options to phase-out our gas plants. For example, Hydro One could upgrade its transmission system to allow us to import an additional 2,000 megawatts of peak Quebec water power at a cost of only approximately $80 million.  That is, Quebec could provide us with twice as much peak power as the TC Energy project at a capital cost that is 97.5 per cent lower.

Yours truly,

Jack Gibbons
Chair, Ontario Clean Air Alliance

**********************